A Texas husband was mistakenly told his wife was speaking to another 911 operator while she lay dead inside their home. He later discovered that both his wife and daughter had been killed in a 2023 shooting.

KXAN reports that the 911 calls were played during the capital murder trial of Shane James, who was convicted on 9 November 2026. The jury rejected James' insanity defence, and he was sentenced to life in prison without parole.

Short's wife, Katherine, 56, and daughter, Lauren, 30, were among four people James killed in Austin on 5 December 2023. Three others were injured during the shooting spree, which followed the killings of James' parents in Bexar County on 4 December 2023.

911 Operator Gave Husband Incorrect Information About Wife

Short called 911 after receiving a doorbell camera notification showing a man kicking down the back door of his Circle C home.

'I can't get ahold of my wife and daughter. I'm terrified,' he told the operator. He explained that both were still inside and that he could not contact them.

Police were dispatched to the property, but Short remained unsure whether officers had reached his family. He called again to ask whether anyone had checked on them.

During the second call, the operator said another call-taker was speaking to his wife. The information briefly gave Short hope that his family was safe.

'Oh, maybe they're okay, maybe it's going to be okay,' he recalled thinking during his testimony.

The operator repeated that his wife was on the phone with another call-taker. Short responded: 'Okay, oh my God, thank God.'

He then asked whether he should return home. The operator advised him to go there, saying there was no indication anything was wrong with his wife.

Short went home and discovered that Katherine and Lauren had been killed.

Austin Police Acknowledge 911 Communication Error

In a statement to KXAN, the Austin Police Department acknowledged that incorrect information had been communicated to Short.

The department said its review confirmed the person speaking to the other call-taker was not his wife. It also acknowledged that the correct information was not promptly communicated to him.

'We understand the gravity of this misinformation and the harm it caused,' the department said. 'It is a tragedy that cannot be undone.'

Police said the shootings involved multiple scenes and victims, creating a rapidly evolving emergency. The call-taker was later informed that the person on the other call was not Short's wife.

The department said it would consider using the incident in future training. The aim is to reinforce accurate communication, accountability and a more victim-centred approach.

Shane James Trial Examined Schizophrenia and Legal Insanity

The 2026 trial also examined James' mental health and whether he understood his actions were wrong.

Both mental health experts who evaluated him agreed that James had schizophrenia. However, they disagreed over whether his condition meant he was legally insane when he carried out the Austin shootings.

The jury ultimately rejected the insanity defence after deliberating for about two hours. James was convicted on four capital murder counts in the Austin case and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Why Accurate 911 Communication Matters

For families waiting to hear whether loved ones are safe, accurate and timely communication can make an enormous difference.

Short's experience shows how incorrect information during an emergency can deepen the trauma already facing victims' relatives. The Austin Police Department acknowledged that its misinformation caused harm that could not be undone.