MAGA-aligned accounts on X published at least 605 near-identical posts between 8 and 11 October claiming that Texas Senate candidate James Talarico had been discharged from an Ohio mental health facility, according to an analysis of activity on the platform.

Talarico, a Democratic state representative, has said he was off the campaign trail with flu. The Lindner Center of Hope in Mason, Ohio, stated on X: 'Representative James Talarico has never received treatment from Lindner Center of Hope.' Talarico reposted the message, adding: 'I've never even been to Ohio.'

The speculation began after Talarico left the campaign trail for nine days at the start of October. His campaign said he was recuperating at home in Austin.

How a Phone Call Became 'Proof' of a Hospital Stay

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton described Talarico as 'missing' and demanded 'proof of life'. Spencer Pratt, the former reality television personality and Los Angeles mayoral hopeful, claimed without evidence that his 'sources' had placed Talarico in 'a mental health facility'.

On 10 October, Caroline Wren, a former Trump fundraiser, shared flight-tracking data for a jet that reportedly flew from Austin to Hamilton, Ohio, near the Lindner Center. She provided no evidence connecting the aircraft to Talarico.

The next day, right‑wing influencer Rhein Amacher posted a 55‑second recording of a call to the centre. In the clip, a woman who appeared to be a staff member says it 'looks like' Talarico 'was just discharged this evening'.

At 1.05pm on 11 October, commentator Nick Sortor wrote on X that an 'Ohio mental hospital CONFIRMS James Talarico was discharged from the facility earlier this week'. The post drew more than seven million views by the following day, and at least 18 accounts repeated it almost word for word.

A longer, six‑minute version of the call, obtained by The Bulwark, adds further context. In that recording, Amacher falsely says he is Talarico's cousin and invents a security 'code' in an attempt to bypass privacy safeguards.

For more than two minutes, the staff member says she cannot find anyone with that name. After a lengthy hold, and still without a matching record, she then suggests 'maybe he's been discharged'.

Read more

Denials, a Public Timeline and the X Amplifier

A centre spokesperson later reiterated its general policy of not confirming or denying whether an individual is or has been a patient, citing privacy and confidentiality. Talarico's spokesman, JT Ennis, described the claim as 'a lie designed to promote a pathetic conspiracy theory'.

Talarico told MS NOW: 'I had the flu.' He added that it was 'wild that someone can just post something on the internet and then the media just runs with it.'

The timing set out by supporters of the claim conflicts with Talarico's public schedule. Amacher said he rang on the evening of 10 October and was told Talarico had 'just' been discharged. That night, Talarico was at a Kacey Musgraves concert in Dallas, and he and other attendees posted photographs.

The previous afternoon he was filmed at the Austin City Limits festival, where his team captioned a video: 'Hate to disappoint the conspiracy theorists, but James is still alive and meeting with voters at ACL today.'

Analysts who reviewed about 14,000 posts related to the story found that early attempts to push the rumour by Pratt and Wren did not significantly gain traction. The volume of posts increased sharply only after Sortor presented Amacher's partial audio as a 'BREAKING EXCLUSIVE'.

In the first hour after that post, 267 accounts joined in, many using near‑identical wording. Some accounts posted the same reply more than 80 times in about two hours.

According to the analysis, rebuttals from ordinary users, the Lindner Center and Talarico were eventually seen more often than the original allegation. It remains unclear who, if anyone, organised or coordinated the larger wave of posts.

Read more