NYC Spa Owner Says 'I'm Afraid All the Time' as Brothel Upstairs Brings Menacing Bosses, Bodily Fluids and 200 Police Calls

Ekaterina Durova says she has called 911 more than 200 times since an alleged brothel opened above her Manhattan spa, where, she claims, men regularly enter by mistake. The landlord of the building at 226 Fifth Avenue is seeking to evict the fourth-floor business, which disputes the allegations.
Durova runs Katya Young Studios on the third floor, directly below Executive Spa. In court papers, the tenant is named as Health Spa NYC LLC. It says it is a legitimate business, and no court has found that prostitution took place.
'It's a nightmare for me that never ends,' Durova told the New York Post. 'I'm afraid all the time.'
Manhattan Spa Says Clients Are Caught in the Middle
Durova says her women-only studio has served about 300 clients a month for four years, offering facials, lymphatic massages and skincare treatments. Prices range from $150 (£120) to $350 (£280).
She says the lift opens directly into her premises, so clients wearing robes can be confronted by men looking for the business upstairs. Durova alleges Executive Spa operates around the clock, with customers roaming shared areas. She also claims bodily fluids have been left in the lift.
Durova says two men she described as bosses of the upstairs business threatened her. One, she alleges, shouted in Russian, 'You are a bitch! I will destroy you.' The words are Durova's account of what was said.
She says she has complained to the landlord since June 2025. After finding advertisements for Executive Spa on escort websites, she contacted city agencies and reported suspected prostitution and an unsafe environment to 311. The city's 311 record shows the complaint was referred to the NYPD.
Durova says police responses to her calls varied. She alleges officers raided the premises on 15 October 2025 and took several women away, but that they returned the next day. The NYPD did not respond to the New York Post's enquiries about the raid.
She has also described women arriving with suitcases, staying briefly and then leaving. Durova told the Post that when she tried to raise the noise with one woman, she appeared disoriented and was wearing little clothing. Those descriptions have not been independently verified.
Eviction Case Turns on Allegations and Evidence
The building's owner, 226 Fifth Ave LLC, has filed to evict the fourth-floor tenant. Court papers say the landlord gave notice that the lease would be terminated on 5 May, citing alleged breaches that it said had not been remedied.
The landlord's filing points to online advertising, including listings on Bedpage in its 'Escorts' section. It argues that the advertisements give it grounds to believe the premises are being used for illicit purposes. The tenant disputes the allegations and says it operates legitimately. The case contains claims, not a finding of criminal conduct.
The landlord's private investigator, Christopher Eng, describes a visit in a sworn affidavit. He says a woman collected a $200 (£160) 'house fee' before taking him to a private room.
After a brief massage, Eng alleges, she touched his intimate parts and offered sexual intercourse for $400 (£320), two encounters for $800 (£640), or oral sex and dancing for $300 (£240).
Eng says he stopped the transaction and left. His affidavit is evidence submitted in the eviction dispute, not a court ruling. Meanwhile, Durova says men still mistake her studio for the business upstairs, where the lift opens directly into her treatment space.