A pregnant Syrian woman's search across seven Japanese hospitals for maternity care provided exclusively by female clinicians has highlighted the challenges Muslim women can face when seeking religiously accommodating healthcare.

The expectant mother, identified as Elham, approached multiple Japanese clinics seeking assurances that only female clinicians would manage her labour.

Under Islamic practice, women observe modesty guidelines regarding parts of the body seen by men outside their immediate families.

However, medical providers stressed practical staffing limits, particularly regarding out-of-hours emergency care.

'If delivery happens at night and only male doctors are available, it becomes quite difficult to accommodate the birth exclusively with female staff,' a hospital representative explained.

During the discussions, a clinician asked how the couple would respond if labour began at night when only male doctors were available. The scenario highlighted the difficulty of guaranteeing exclusively female medical teams around the clock.

Religious Requirements and Medical Exceptions Under Islamic Law

Islamic jurisprudence prioritises female obstetricians for childbirth, but standard legal rulings permit exceptions during pressing medical need.

An official fatwa or legal ruling in Islamic law issued on maternal care suggests that examining private areas is prohibited 'save for an urgent need'.

The ruling clarifies that care under a male physician is explicitly permissible when no female doctor is available, when an emergency forces a patient to the nearest hospital, or during complex surgeries.

Scholars maintain that while families should make reasonable efforts to secure female doctors, emergency medical situations alter these restrictions to safeguard life.

Despite these established dispensations, tensions over gender preferences in maternity care have previously escalated into severe incidents abroad.

Read more

In May 2016, a Jordanian obstetrician was shot and wounded in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, by a father who objected to a male doctor delivering his child.

Social Friction Grows Amid Shifting Japanese Demographics

The hospital dispute quickly prompted strong reactions online, reflecting broader unease over demographic changes in Japan.

'If things continue like this, the next demand will be "increase female doctors!"' one Japanese social media user wrote. 'I don't mean to criticise this couple, but this will lead to more cases like this.'

Waseda University professor emeritus Hirofumi Tanada tells Japan Today that Japan's Muslim population has grown significantly, rising from around 110,000 in 2010 to roughly 420,000.

Japan's ageing population and declining birth rate have contributed to demographic and labour-market challenges. Births fell in 45 of the country's 47 prefectures in 2025, according to government figures.

The government has expanded foreign worker visa programmes to fill shortfalls in sectors like logistics, agriculture, and healthcare.

Yet the transition from welcoming short-term tourists to accommodating permanent residents has produced administrative and social hurdles, ranging from unpermitted mosque disputes to municipal bans on traditional ground burials.

Hospital Protocols Balance Patient Preferences

Japanese medical facilities have sought to respect individual cultural preferences where resources permit, but operational constraints remain firm.

Maternity wards operate under strict staffing rotas, where on-call coverage frequently depends on rotating staff across unpredictable shift patterns.

Guaranteeing single-gender medical teams throughout an entire labour process remains logistically difficult for regional hospitals managing standard staff numbers.

Medical ethics guidelines emphasise that maternal and foetal survival override non-clinical preferences during acute obstetrics complications.

Healthcare administrators continue to advise expectant parents with specific cultural requirements to establish emergency delivery plans with regional clinics well before their due dates.

Read more