People trying to quit vaping for their health are, in growing numbers, relapsing into something doctors consider worse. Data from Action on Smoking and Health shows some smokers and dual users who stop vaping turn back to cigarettes instead.

Addiction specialists trace the relapse to one mechanism: dependence itself. Dr Mark Block, chief of thoracic surgery at Memorial Healthcare System, said nicotine's real danger lies in how fast it hooks the brain.

'Nicotine does have harmful effects on the body, but its most damaging characteristic is its ability to rapidly create dependence, keeping many people trapped in a cycle of addiction,' Block said. That trap, he added, is what pulls people back to cigarettes.

Trent Carter, a board-certified nurse practitioner and CEO of Renew Health in New Mexico, said the shift makes sense once compared. Vaping becomes constant throughout the day, he said, while a cigarette forces a pause.

'Subconsciously, you may not even realize that you're constantly vaping throughout the day, whereas with cigarettes you feel like you're more in control,' Carter said. Lighting a cigarette means stepping outside, he added, building in a break vaping never demands.

Read more

Potency Fuels Harsh Withdrawal

Vaping devices often deliver far more nicotine per puff than a cigarette. Many use concentrated nicotine salts, and the higher the dose, the harder it becomes to walk away, specialists say.

'If you're consuming a large amount with every single puff, it's going to be harder to stop,' Carter said. Nicotine dependence alters brain chemistry by stimulating dopamine and other mood-related neurotransmitters, according to Cleveland Clinic.

Part of the risk is what users actually inhale. Vaping liquid contains chemicals that go unregulated by the FDA and vary batch to batch, including formaldehyde and metals from heating elements, according to lung health researchers.

What looks like vapour is really an aerosol of suspended particles, he noted. Because the lungs have reserve capacity, a 5 to 10 per cent loss of function can go entirely unnoticed.

Cut off abruptly, high-volume use can trigger fast, severe withdrawal: cravings, irritability, sleep disturbances and brain fog. Patches or gum alone often cannot keep pace with it, Carter said.

'While a patch or gum could definitely help with the nicotine cravings, if you're not addressing the behavioral aspect of it, then you're really falling short,' he said, citing untreated anxiety as a hidden driver.

Breaking the Dependency Cycle

Switching back to cigarettes reintroduces toxins, tar and carbon monoxide, undoing progress made by quitting. Some superficial damage may ease within a week or two, Block has said, though scar tissue from chronic exposure never reverses.

Persistent cough, chest pain, shortness of breath or fever are warning signs, Block has said. They call for a specialist, not another switch between products.

Rather than swapping nicotine sources, specialists recommend medically supervised strategies pairing behavioural therapy with gradual nicotine reduction. Quit coaches are available free through 1-800-QUIT-NOW.

'The goal shouldn't be to find another way to consume nicotine,' Carter said. 'The goal should be to treat the dependence itself,' he added, framing recovery around the root cause, not the substitute.

The FDA has approved seven medications to help people quit smoking, and pairing them with counselling raises the odds of success further, according to federal guidance. No vaping product has been approved by the FDA as a quit-smoking aid.

Carter urges anyone caught in the cycle to build self-awareness and consult a licensed addiction or mental health specialist for a recovery plan. That approach treats the dependence rather than trading one habit for another.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Why do some people relapse to smoking after quitting vaping?
    Some people relapse to smoking due to the dependence mechanism of nicotine, which rapidly creates addiction and can lead individuals back to cigarettes.
  • What are the risks of vaping compared to smoking?
    Vaping can deliver more nicotine per puff than cigarettes and contains unregulated chemicals, posing risks such as altered brain chemistry and potential lung damage.
  • What strategies are recommended for quitting vaping?
    Medically supervised strategies that combine behavioural therapy with gradual nicotine reduction are recommended, along with FDA-approved medications and counselling.
Read more