A Missouri substitute teacher says low pay pushed her to create adult content on OnlyFans. But after her online work was discovered, she lost her school assignments and feared she could no longer volunteer at her son's school.

Sheena Sittner, 42, had worked in the Parkway School District in suburban St Louis for more than two years. She said the extra income helped cover tuition, student loans and everyday living expenses. She was also taking classes towards a criminal justice degree, while her two older children were in college.

The mother had maintained her OnlyFans account for more than two years alongside her teaching work. She told local broadcaster KTVI that better teacher pay could reduce the pressure on women to seek income through online content.

'If teachers were paid better, women wouldn't have to resort to online content creation,' she said. 'Sex sells.'

Substitute Teacher Removed From School Assignments

Sittner worked through Kelly Education, a company that hires substitute teachers. In September 2026, Kelly Education removed her from school assignments after a manager cited reports of her OnlyFans activity, according to The Washington Post. Emails she shared with KTVI said she was suspended pending termination and told not to contact schools or districts.

Sittner feared this would also stop her from taking part in her son's school activities. 'I can find another job. I can handle the backlash and the criticism, but when it affects my child or my children, that's where I draw the line,' she told KTVI.

The school district later confirmed she could still volunteer as a parent. Kelly Education also clarified that its restriction applied only to her teaching role, not her involvement in her child's education.

OnlyFans Became a Source of Financial Support

Sittner said her substitute teaching work paid about $140 (£106) a day, while her OnlyFans content could earn around $140 an hour. She said the online work had made a significant difference to her family's finances.

The publicity surrounding her removal from teaching assignments also brought new subscribers, according to The Washington Post. Her husband reportedly reduced time spent on his own business to help manage the increased demand.

OnlyFans has grown into a major creator platform. Its latest company accounts, for the year ending November 2025, recorded about 5.06 million creator accounts and 437.1 million fan accounts.

Fans spent approximately $7.84 billion (£5.95 billion) through the platform during that financial year.

Although some OnlyFans creators earn thousands or millions, most accounts generate far less. Based on the platform's 2025 figures, average fan spending worked out at roughly $131 (£103) per creator account each month, before OnlyFans' 20% fee. After the fee, that would amount to approximately $105 (£83). These figures are averages across registered accounts, not a measure of what an active creator typically earns.

Online Work Can Carry Professional Risks

Sittner said she understood that her adult content could eventually become public. She told KTVI that anything posted online could remain accessible, even years later.

She did not know who had discovered her account. In an interview with The Washington Post, she said the publicity had unexpectedly helped her online business, although losing her teaching role remained frustrating.

First Amendment lawyer Corey Silverstein told the newspaper that employers increasingly use third-party search firms and artificial intelligence-powered visual recognition tools to identify workers' online accounts. He advised people considering online content creation to review their employment contracts and understand the possible consequences.

Sittner said she had always kept her online work separate from her professional and family life. Despite losing her substitute teaching assignments, she plans to remain involved in her child's education.