OnlyFans creator Michaela Rylaarsdam, 32, was sentenced to four years in prison on 8 June 2026 after pleading guilty to involuntary manslaughter in the suffocation death of a paying client during a filmed fetish encounter in California.

San Diego Superior Court Judge Brad Weinreb imposed the sentence following Rylaarsdam's guilty plea in May. The victim, Michael Dale, 55, suffered a fatal asphyxia injury following a fetish encounter at his home in Escondido on 17 April 2023. He was taken to a hospital following the incident, where he was later declared brain dead.

Rylaarsdam had initially faced a second-degree murder charge, but accepted a plea agreement allowing her to plead guilty to involuntary manslaughter, avoiding a murder trial.

Michael Dale's Final Encounter

Dale met Rylaarsdam through an online adult-services site in the weeks before his death, according to prosecutors. They continued communicating online, and Dale paid her more than $11,000 (£8,300) for messages and planned fetish activities.

Rylaarsdam travelled from San Bernardino County to his home to carry out the paid encounter, parts of which were recorded for her OnlyFans account.

Investigators said footage appeared to show Dale restrained and unable to breathe freely during the session. According to a court affidavit reviewed by the Los Angeles Times, detectives recovered recordings from Rylaarsdam's phone, including one made shortly before the emergency call.

Rylaarsdam subsequently contacted emergency services and attempted resuscitation as police responded to the scene. Dale was taken to a hospital, where he was declared brain dead and later removed from life support. The medical examiner ruled that Dale died from asphyxia and classified it as a homicide.

Michaela Rylaarsdam's Sentencing

During her sentencing, the OnlyFans creator apologised to Dale's relatives and said she wished she could reverse what had happened. Her lawyer, Daniel Cohen, said the death had been accidental and that she had not intended to kill him. Cohen also told the court she had sought therapy after the incident.

Judge Weinreb said the conduct was extremely reckless despite the absence of an intention to kill. Deputy District Attorney David Jarman said Rylaarsdam had knowingly disregarded the danger to Dale's life.

Dale's family did not attend the hearing but supported the resolution, according to prosecutors. Cohen said time already spent in custody since February 2025 could shorten Rylaarsdam's remaining detention.

Asphyxia and Oxygen-Related Brain Injury

Asphyxia occurs when the body cannot obtain sufficient oxygen, potentially depriving the brain and other organs of the supply needed to function properly. The US National Library of Medicine says cerebral hypoxia can cause brain cells to begin dying within minutes.

Severe oxygen deprivation can result in unconsciousness, permanent neurological injury or death, even when emergency treatment is attempted.

Medical guidance also identifies confusion, impaired coordination and loss of consciousness as possible signs of inadequate oxygen reaching the brain. The Cleveland Clinic describes cerebral hypoxia as a medical emergency requiring immediate treatment, with outcomes depending partly on how long oxygen delivery was disrupted.

The US National Library of Medicine advises seeking immediate medical attention for anyone showing signs of cerebral hypoxia. Dale had underlying medical conditions, including high blood pressure and diabetes, according to court testimony. However, the medical examiner concluded that asphyxia was the cause of death.