A Hawaii woman says genetic tests identified her gynaecologist as the biological father of her twin sons, decades after the boys were conceived using what she believed was anonymous donor sperm. The case has prompted calls for Hawaii to introduce a fertility fraud law targeting doctors who allegedly use their own sperm without patients' knowledge or consent.

Victoria Snyder sought artificial insemination from Oahu gynaecologist William McKenzie in 1993 and requested sperm from an anonymous Filipino donor. She gave birth to twin boys in 1994. When her sons underwent genetic testing at age 23, the results linked them to McKenzie, according to a lawsuit Snyder filed in 2019. McKenzie denied using his sperm without her consent.

Victoria Snyder's Lawsuit and Its Outcome

The lawsuit accused McKenzie of fraud, breach of contract and medical negligence. Snyder said she would not have agreed to the treatment had she known the doctor was the sperm source, and the complaint described emotional, psychological and physical harm.

On 30 April 2020, both sides agreed to dismiss the case with prejudice, preventing the claims from being refiled. Any settlement terms remain undisclosed to the public.

McKenzie worked as an obstetrician and gynaecologist in Wahiawa and Mililani for more than five decades. He delivered more than 9,000 babies, according to local reporting, and retired from private practice in 2021. His medical licence remained active in 2026, as per a report by the Honolulu Civil Beat.

Other Families Report Possible Connections

Civil Beat interviewed members of two other families who said their children were also fathered by McKenzie. They requested anonymity because they feared publicity could harm their relatives. Their accounts suggest Snyder's sons have multiple half-siblings, although the total number remains unknown.

The allegations gained wider attention in April 2026 after an Instagram user identifying herself as a former patient claimed McKenzie had inseminated dozens of women with his sperm. Civil Beat could not verify the number, and the woman declined to provide supporting information.

Some commenters identified themselves as McKenzie's children, but those claims were not independently established.

Fertility Fraud Law and Health Risks

In June, state representative Amy Perruso, who said McKenzie had also been her gynaecologist, announced plans for legislation addressing fertility fraud. She proposed making the conduct a Class C felony and allowing affected patients, spouses and children to sue. Hawaii had no specific criminal law prohibiting doctors from secretly substituting their own sperm during insemination.

Lawyers interviewed by Civil Beat said existing sexual assault laws could be difficult to apply because patients had consented to a medical procedure, although not to the alleged substitution. McKenzie faced no criminal charges.

The issue has also drawn attention to the broader consequences of unknown biological parentage. The American Society for Reproductive Medicine recommends collecting detailed family health histories from anonymous donors and providing them to recipients. These records can help assess inherited risks, although they cannot identify every potential condition.

The Hawaii Medical Board approved a $750 (£570) fine against McKenzie in December 2023 for failing to disclose a malpractice claim when renewing his medical licence. A September report found no formal board complaint over the insemination allegation.