Woman Texted 'Maybe I Did Kill Him' After Allegedly Watching Roommate Die From Overdose for Hours, Police Say

Phoebe Allen, 21, has been charged with second-degree manslaughter over the April 2025 overdose death of her 18-year-old roommate in Southington, Connecticut.
An arrest warrant says a witness told police Allen had seen him dead hours before emergency services were called. It also cites a text message in which Allen allegedly wrote, 'maybe I did kill him.'
The warrant does not allege Allen watched the man die. It describes a witness' account that she found him dead hours before calling for help.
Allen was arrested in New Britain on 8 October 2026 and held on a $175,000 (£132,600) bond. Court records show she has pleaded not guilty and is due to appear at New Britain Superior Court on 12 December for a pre-trial hearing. The warrant was made public on 13 November.
Southington police were called to an address on 29 April 2025 after receiving a report that an 18-year-old man was not breathing. The state Office of the Chief Medical Examiner determined he died from acute intoxication caused by the combined effects of methamphetamine and benzodiazepines. His name has not been publicly released.
What the Phoebe Allen Warrant Says
Allen initially told police the man had become paranoid and that she had tried to help him, according to the warrant. She said she found him on the bathroom floor, 'blue and cold to the touch and not breathing,' with liquid coming from his mouth.
She also told police he had a history of mental illness and might have been addicted to fentanyl, the warrant says.
A witness told investigators that Allen had described giving the man an injection of either fentanyl or methamphetamine and seeing him dead hours before calling for help. The witness said Allen referred to it as his 'last shot.'
The witness also recalled Allen saying: 'I don't know why I did not go in to check on him, I knew something was wrong.' According to the warrant, Allen told the witness that she sometimes helped the man with his injections and that he had injected her.
Allen told police she had given him two sips of a drink containing a white powder she believed was methadone. She denied injecting him on the day he died during an interview, although the warrant says she had told other officers that she did.
The Messages at the Centre of the Case
The warrant cites text messages Allen allegedly sent after the man's death. In one, she wrote: 'maybe I did kill him'. In another, she wrote: 'I should've forced him to go to the hospital and hate me forever,' followed by: 'but at least he'd be alive.'
Police allege Allen knew the drugs were illegal and that the man had an addiction. An investigating officer wrote in the warrant: 'Instead of assisting him in seeking medical care, she held him in a headlock style position armed with a flashlight to assist him in ingesting narcotics.'
The warrant says investigators questioned Allen's credibility after determining that two of her statements were untruthful. It sets out the allegations and evidence police relied on in bringing the charge. Allen is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
The medical examiner determined the cause of death. The warrant details police allegations about the events beforehand, including when Allen realised the man needed emergency help.