Eighteen children underwent surgery at Dr Gray's Hospital in Elgin after NHS Grampian ordered paediatric operations to stop, chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight has confirmed. She said no patients were harmed but acknowledged that the failure was unacceptable.

Skaife-Knight told STV News on Tuesday that the health board had written to all the families affected. 'Of course that should never have happened; that's completely unacceptable,' she said, apologising to the families and patients.

How the Suspension Failed at Dr Gray's

NHS Grampian paused emergency paediatric surgery at Dr Gray's Hospital in June, with defined exceptions, after concerns were raised about the quality and safety of care.

Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) carried out an unannounced inspection at the Moray hospital in April. The inspection raised concerns, including the availability of staff trained in advanced paediatric life support.

On 9 July, the health board extended the suspension to all elective paediatric surgery. Medical director Dr Hugh Farrow-Bishop said the pause then covered all planned and emergency surgery, with defined exceptions.

The board later told HIS that elective paediatric dental and ear, nose and throat operations had continued until 6 August, nearly a month after the extended suspension began. HIS said this affected its confidence in the reliability and consistency of information supplied by the board.

HIS published its report on 12 November. It found weaknesses in leadership, management and clinical governance, and described a 'them and us' culture between Dr Gray's and Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.

'Nothing Has Been Learned'

The report also raised concerns about the board's handling of a patient's death during surgery. It said no patient was harmed by the operations carried out after the suspension, while noting that the failure to implement a safety measure as intended was concerning.

NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight, who joined the board in September 2025 and asked HIS to conduct the review in May, accepted responsibility for the findings. The health board has apologised to patients and staff.

Former senior surgeon Professor Zygmunt Krukowski, who left the board in 2015, said he first raised concerns about patient safety and clinical governance in 2014. He said 'nothing has been learned' in the intervening decade and described the situation as 'deeply distressing.'

NHS Grampian Faces Demands for Change

First Minister John Swinney described the failures at NHS Grampian as 'reprehensible.' Health Secretary Angela Constance called the findings 'extremely serious' and said she expected immediate changes to medical leadership.

She has appointed an external team of senior NHS leaders with expertise in patient safety and clinical governance to support the board.

Constance told MSPs the problems were 'longstanding and systemic.' She said she learned of issues at Dr Gray's Hospital in August but did not see the Healthcare Improvement Scotland report until 29 October. She also raised questions about the accuracy of information provided to ministers.

NHS Grampian is addressing a backlog of more than 100 overdue reviews into serious patient safety cases, chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight said. Senior medical and nursing staff are overseeing the reviews. Professor Graham Ellis has been appointed interim medical director.

Constance said the board could face escalation to Stage 5 of the NHS Scotland support and intervention framework if it failed to make 'demonstrable progress.' The board is expected to show urgent improvements by Christmas.

The Scottish Government has said paediatric surgery at Dr Gray's must resume 'as soon as it is safe to do so.' Skaife-Knight said NHS Grampian was working to restore the service by the end of the year and denied plans to reduce services at the hospital. Constance said Dr Gray's would remain a key asset for patient care in the north.