Father Claims Daughter Accused of Posing as 14-Year-Old to Sexually Abuse 5 Boys Is the 'Real Victim,' Cites IQ of 72

'She's defective, mentally defective,' says the father of a Florida woman accused of posing as a 14-year-old to sexually abuse five middle school boys. Josh Zinger insists Alyssa Ann Zinger, 25, who once scored 72 on an IQ test, is 'the victim'.
Her father said she grew up in a 'good Christian home' in suburban Tampa while battling ADHD, ADD, OCD, Tourette's syndrome and anorexia. He said she has seen 10 to 12 psychologists and psychiatrists in her life.
Father Cites Mental Health History
'She had a lot of problems growing up,' Josh Zinger said. He said she had scored 72 on an IQ test, below the population average of 100. However, an IQ score alone is not sufficient to establish an intellectual disability.
He argued that Florida law prohibits sexual activity with someone who is legally considered 'mentally defective'. However, the law's definition is more specific than an IQ score or a mental health diagnosis. 'In all actuality, she is the victim,' he said.
He claimed a boy found her social media account, hosted her at his apartment for five months and introduced her to school-age friends. He said the boy knew her real age and that she was 'mentally unstable'.
Alyssa Zinger was arrested in 2023 after allegedly posing as a 14-year-old online and having dozens of sexual encounters with a boy aged 12 to 15. In April 2024, investigators announced additional charges after identifying four more alleged victims.
She remains in jail on felony charges, including lewd or lascivious battery, lewd or lascivious molestation, child pornography offences and sexual cyber harassment. Her father said he expects no plea deal, no sex offender registry and a time-served sentence.
What Research Says About Risk
Research has found associations between intellectual disability and both sexual offending and victimisation, although the absolute risks are low and the findings do not establish that intellectual disability causes either outcome. Josh Zinger did not cite a diagnosis of intellectual disability for his daughter, only her IQ score.
Antti Latvala and colleagues, writing in Psychological Medicine, studied 1,232,564 people born in Sweden from 1980 to 1991. They found intellectual disability was independently linked to sexual crimes and victimisation, though absolute risks were low.
Men with intellectual disability and comorbid ADHD had the highest risk of sexual offending, with hazard ratios of 9.4 to 11.0. The team found the higher risk of violent offending was largely explained by comorbid ADHD.
A focus group study led by Gøril Brevik Svae, in the Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities, involved 20 participants. It said people with intellectual disabilities can be abused and can also display harmful sexual behaviour.
Participants came from hospital-based habilitation centres, community residences, schools and the criminal justice system. The study found a lack of education and guidelines for carers and said people with intellectual disabilities may lack understanding of consent.
Impulse Control and Boundaries
A separate study published in BMC Public Health interviewed seven adults with mild intellectual disabilities about their understanding of personal and sexual boundaries. Participants were unsure about consent in sexual activity, though many could explain the concept in other contexts.
Palo Alto University describes sexual impulsivity as acting on sexual urges without weighing risks, often with poor impulse control. It lists genetics, trauma, attachment issues, bipolar disorder and alcohol or drug use as contributing factors.
The university says treatment typically involves psychotherapy, such as cognitive behavioural therapy or schema therapy. It adds that medication may be prescribed for co-occurring conditions.
Risk Factors Are Not Excuses
Isabelle Daigneault's team, in the American Journal on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities, found children with intellectual disabilities were over three times likelier to have a corroborated sexual abuse report. They had more health consultations afterwards.
None of the research cited here says low IQ, intellectual disability or mental health disorders automatically cause sexual abuse. The studies describe risk factors and barriers to prevention, and none suggests these conditions excuse criminal behaviour.